11.19.26 Draft in Progress
What committed warming means for you
Committed global warming means the additional warming expected from the climate system’s delayed response, under a clearly stated assumption about future emissions or atmospheric concentrations. When a temperature level is reached, some parts of the climate system are still adjusting. How much more warming follows depends on what happens next. A temperature number alone does not determine the answer. [1], [17]
What equilibrium means—and why warming takes time
Equilibrium means a long-term balance between the energy Earth absorbs from sunlight and the energy it releases back into space. Adding carbon dioxide initially disrupts that balance: Earth retains more energy than it releases. The planet then warms until it can release enough energy to restore the balance.
Equilibrium climate sensitivity, or ECS, asks: How much warmer would Earth eventually become if atmospheric carbon dioxide doubled from its pre-industrial level and stayed doubled? The answer includes warming-amplifying responses such as increased water vapor and changes in clouds. That adjustment takes time because the deep ocean warms slowly. Approaching the new balance can require centuries to millennia. Therefore, the warming experienced along the way can be considerably less than the eventual warming under those fixed conditions.
For example, an ECS of 3°C means approximately 3°C of total warming from the doubled CO₂, measured from the original pre-industrial climate. It does not mean adding another 3°C to whatever warming has already occurred. Standard ECS also excludes some very slow responses, such as major changes in the ice sheets.
- The temperature we experience can lag behind the global warming supported by a fixed heat-trapping atmosphere. Homes, farms, water supplies and coastlines may face continuing changes even after emissions fall. See delayed warming.
- There is no scientifically established rule that reaching 1.5°C automatically commits Earth to 2°C, or that reaching 2°C automatically commits it to 3°C. The result depends on emissions, greenhouse gas concentrations, aerosols, feedbacks and time. See the threshold comparison.
- Cutting emissions still changes the outcome. Net-zero CO₂ can approximately halt further CO₂-caused surface warming over decades, while continued emissions keep adding heat. This makes both emissions reduction and practical preparation valuable. [1], [13]
Five more facts that make this committed future global warming issue urgent and understandable
- “Nothing else changes” has several meanings. Keeping annual emissions unchanged, keeping concentrations unchanged, and stopping emissions are different experiments. They produce different futures.
- The ocean creates a delay. It absorbs heat while the surface warms. Under fixed forcing, the surface and deep ocean take a long time to approach balance. The thermostat has a delay; it has not misplaced the instruction manual.
- Clean air changes the balance. Some pollution particles cool the planet. Removing them can reveal warming that they had masked, while reducing methane works in the cooling direction. [6], [10]
- Here is the puzzle to keep in mind. How can scientists report both almost no extra warming after emissions stop and several degrees of increased "equilibrium" warming? The answer is in what each calculation holds constant.
- There is useful, achievable hope. Faster CO₂ reductions, methane cuts, ecosystem protection and better preparation reduce different parts of the risk. Start with what to do next.
Quick navigation
- Three different futures
- The comparison from 1.5°C to 5°C
- Published estimates and credible differences
- Delayed warming and the time required
- If emissions continue at the same rate
- Aerosols and methane
- Tipping points and commitments to damage
- CO₂ and CO₂ equivalent
- What to do next
- Conclusion
- Frequently asked questions
- Glossary
- AI Prompt Support
- Linked bibliography
Three futures that must be kept separate
| Assumption after the starting point | What happens | Relevant time window |
|---|---|---|
| Net CO₂ emissions become zero | Atmospheric CO₂ can fall as land and ocean absorb it. That cooling influence roughly offsets delayed warming in many models. Other climate drivers must be specified separately. | Decades; commonly assessed at 50 years. |
| Greenhouse gas concentrations and other forcing stay fixed | The warming influence remains. The surface and ocean continue moving toward a warmer equilibrium. Maintaining concentrations generally requires continuing some emissions to replace natural uptake. | Decades to centuries, with a long tail beyond 1,000 years. |
| Annual CO₂ emissions remain positive | Additional emissions accumulate and produce more warming. This is partly a commitment created by future actions. | Warming continues while cumulative net emissions rise. |
The first two cases are often confused. Zero emissions does not mean a constant atmospheric concentration. A declining CO₂ concentration can prevent much of the equilibrium warming calculated for a concentration that is artificially held fixed. [2], [8]
Illustration 1 One starting temperature can lead to different futures

Stopping the flow of CO₂, holding the amount of CO₂ in the air fixed, and continuing the flow are three different instructions to the climate system. The table above is the accessible text version of this illustration.
What reaching 1.5°C to 5°C can and cannot tell us
The comparison below uses 0.5°C increments. “Reaching” means a sustained climate state, not a single unusually hot year. WMO distinguishes annual temperature records from long-term warming assessed over decades. [16]
No major assessment provides an automatic additional-warming ladder for these eight thresholds. To calculate a fixed-concentration endpoint, scientists also need the forcing, ocean heat uptake, feedbacks and the history of how that state was reached. “Not established” in the table means that the threshold alone does not supply a defensible number.
| Sustained starting warming | If net CO₂ emissions become zero | If atmospheric forcing stays fixed |
|---|---|---|
| 1.5°C | Small additional CO₂ warming is the central expectation in relevant mitigation conditions; no separately assessed 1.5°C-specific range is supplied here. | Additional warming is possible while forcing remains above the level compatible with that temperature. The total cannot be inferred from temperature alone. |
| 2.0°C | About 2°C remains the central expectation. The AR6 reference result of roughly −0.3 to +0.3°C translates to about 1.7–2.3°C at 50 years in that idealized context. | Additional warming is possible while forcing remains above the level compatible with that temperature. The total cannot be inferred from temperature alone. |
| 2.5°C | No assessed threshold-specific range. A near-zero central result at lower warming is not a guarantee here; cumulative emissions and feedbacks matter. | Additional warming is possible while forcing remains above the level compatible with that temperature. The total cannot be inferred from temperature alone. |
| 3.0°C | No assessed threshold-specific range. A near-zero central result at lower warming is not a guarantee here; cumulative emissions and feedbacks matter. | Additional warming is possible while forcing remains above the level compatible with that temperature. The total cannot be inferred from temperature alone. |
| 3.5°C | No assessed threshold-specific range. A near-zero central result at lower warming is not a guarantee here; cumulative emissions and feedbacks matter. | Additional warming is possible while forcing remains above the level compatible with that temperature. The total cannot be inferred from temperature alone. |
| 4.0°C | No assessed threshold-specific range. A near-zero central result at lower warming is not a guarantee here; cumulative emissions and feedbacks matter. | Additional warming is possible while forcing remains above the level compatible with that temperature. The total cannot be inferred from temperature alone. |
| 4.5°C | No assessed threshold-specific range. A near-zero central result at lower warming is not a guarantee here; cumulative emissions and feedbacks matter. | Additional warming is possible while forcing remains above the level compatible with that temperature. The total cannot be inferred from temperature alone. |
| 5.0°C | No assessed threshold-specific range. A near-zero central result at lower warming is not a guarantee here; cumulative emissions and feedbacks matter. | Additional warming is possible while forcing remains above the level compatible with that temperature. The total cannot be inferred from temperature alone. |
Timescale for the zero-CO₂ reference: 50 years after cessation, usually expressed as a 20-year average centered on that time. The IPCC assessed the magnitude as likely below 0.3°C, with low confidence about whether the change is positive or negative. This reference concerns an idealized cumulative-emissions experiment associated with roughly 2°C warming; it is not a universal uncertainty band for every future state. [1], [3]
Timescale for fixed forcing: adjustment begins within years and continues through decades and centuries. Approaching full equilibrium can require millennia. No single waiting period applies to all eight starting temperatures. [9], [19]
What credible studies actually report
These studies do not all ask the same question. The columns identify whether a number is additional warming after a starting point or total warming above pre-industrial conditions. Historical estimates keep their original starting conditions; they have not been silently relabeled as estimates for 2026.
| Study and conditions | Temperature result | Time |
|---|---|---|
| IPCC AR6 assessment of CO₂-only zero emissions [1] | Additional change likely between about −0.3°C and +0.3°C; central expectation close to zero. | 50 years after CO₂ cessation. |
| MacDougall et al. 2020 CO₂-only cessation after 1,000 PgC cumulative emissions [2] | Additional change across models: −0.36 to +0.29°C. At 2,000 PgC, a smaller model subset gives −0.40 to +0.52°C. These are model spreads, not probability intervals. | 50 years after cessation. |
| Sanderson et al. 2025 flat10MIP [4] | Positive and negative zero-emissions commitments remain. The magnitude is about 30% smaller on average than in the earlier concentration-driven comparison. | 50-year commitment metric. |
| Hohn et al. 2026 one-model parameter ensemble [5] | Across tested budgets and emission rates, median additional changes span −0.10 to +0.16°C. Interquartile widths span 0.06–0.15°C. These are not a universal 90% range. | 50 years after cessation. |
| Mauritsen and Pincus 2017 fossil-fuel-cessation framework [6] | Total warming: 1.3°C, with a 0.9–2.3°C range, within the century; an alternative including ocean carbon uptake gives 1.1°C, range 0.7–1.8°C. Their equilibrium estimate is 1.5°C, range 0.9–3.6°C. Ranges are 5th–95th percentiles. | By 2100; equilibrium on much longer timescales. |
| Zhou et al. 2021 fixed total forcing with stronger pattern correction [7] | Total equilibrium warming: 2.31°C, range 1.26–10.3°C. With an alternative sea-surface-temperature dataset: 1.69°C, range 1.18–4.50°C. These are 5th–95th-percentile estimates within that framework. | Equilibrium, not a dated 2100 projection. |
| Zhou et al. 2021 constant long-lived forcing [7] | Total warming by 2100: 1.75°C, range 1.21–2.45°C. Eventual total equilibrium: 2.81°C, range 1.15–16.2°C. Both are 5th–95th-percentile intervals after their stronger pattern correction. | By 2100, or eventual equilibrium, using the study’s historical reference conditions. |
| Frölicher and Paynter 2015 CO₂ cessation at 2°C in one Earth system model [11] | About +0.5°C additional warming, giving about 2.5°C total. | About 1,000 years after cessation in the experiment; warming develops over multiple centuries. |
| Hansen et al. 2023 equilibrium including slow feedbacks [8], [19] | About 10°C total equilibrium warming for the paper’s greenhouse gas amount, reduced to about 8°C with its human-made aerosol cooling. These two scenarios are not an 8–10°C probability range. | Millennia for full adjustment; no validated arrival year. |
| Historical IPCC fixed year-2000 concentration experiment [17] | About +0.6°C additional warming over the twenty-first century. This is not a new estimate for today’s atmosphere. | About 100 years from year-2000 conditions. |
The pattern effect means that the location of ocean warming changes how efficiently Earth releases energy. In Zhou and colleagues’ analysis, different estimates of that effect change both the center and the upper tail. Their large upper values remain part of the published picture; they are not an established ceiling or a forecast that Earth will reach those temperatures by a particular year. Very wide equilibrium tails indicate weak constraints within that calculation; they are not a ranking of probable future worlds. [7]
Hansen and colleagues explicitly state that their equilibrium warming is not committed warming: rapid greenhouse gas reductions would prevent much of it. Keeping their high-end result and its condition together is essential. [8]
Why fixed concentrations can produce a delayed temperature boost
Imagine a large pot of water on a low burner. Its present temperature does not tell you its eventual temperature if the heat input remains unchanged. The ocean is more complicated than a pot, but the delay is real: a fixed atmospheric forcing can support a warmer future climate than the one experienced today. Lowering the forcing changes that destination.
Mainstream and higher sensitivity estimates
Equilibrium climate sensitivity, or ECS, is the eventual global surface warming after CO₂ doubles and stays doubled, with the feedbacks included in that definition. IPCC AR6 gives a best estimate of 3°C, a likely range of 2.5–4°C and a very likely range of 2–5°C. Values above 5°C are not ruled out. [12]
Hansen and colleagues’ 2023 analysis gives 4.8°C ±1.2°C, expressed as a two-standard-deviation uncertainty, or roughly 3.6–6.0°C. Their 2025 paper discusses a 4.5°C sensitivity case. These are higher-sensitivity alternatives, not interchangeable probability intervals with the IPCC ranges. [8], [9]
For doubled CO₂, those numbers describe the eventual total response of the experiment. They do not say that a real-world 1.5°C crossing must be multiplied by 4.8/3.0. ECS alone does not determine warming after net-zero emissions.
Illustration 2 How much warming can remain after a century

Hansen and colleagues describe approximate response fractions of 40% after 10 years, 60% after 100 years and 90% after 1,000 years for a suddenly imposed doubled-CO₂ forcing. Applying those fractions produces the worked example below. [9]
| Time after sudden doubling | 3.4°C equilibrium example | 4.5°C equilibrium example |
|---|---|---|
| 10 years | About 1.4°C realized | About 1.8°C realized |
| 100 years | About 2.0°C realized; about 1.4°C remains to equilibrium | About 2.7°C realized; about 1.8°C remains to equilibrium |
| 1,000 years | About 3.1°C realized | About 4.1°C realized |
| Eventual equilibrium | 3.4°C total | 4.5°C total |
The clock starts when the forcing is imposed. It does not restart when the temperature later crosses 1.5°C or 2°C. The fractions illustrate thermal delay; they are not a countdown from today, and they should not be applied to the remaining warming after an arbitrary crossing.
What if annual CO₂ emissions simply stay the same
If “nothing changes” means continued positive emissions, there is no single final temperature commitment: cumulative CO₂ keeps increasing. For a transparent illustration, assume 40 billion tonnes of CO₂ per year, broadly near recent global emissions, and hold non-CO₂ forcing constant. This round figure is a chosen scenario, not a prediction of future emissions. [20]
The IPCC’s transient climate response to cumulative emissions, or TCRE, gives a central estimate of 0.45°C per 1,000 billion tonnes of CO₂, with a likely range of 0.27–0.63°C. The calculation is simple: annual emissions × years × warming per tonne. [13]
| More years at 40 GtCO₂ per year | New cumulative CO₂ | Calculated additional CO₂ warming |
|---|---|---|
| 10 years | 400 GtCO₂ | +0.18°C; sensitivity band +0.11 to +0.25°C |
| 25 years | 1,000 GtCO₂ | +0.45°C; sensitivity band +0.27 to +0.63°C |
| 50 years | 2,000 GtCO₂ | +0.90°C; sensitivity band +0.54 to +1.26°C |
The next table adds that calculated CO₂ contribution to each starting temperature. It assumes zero central CO₂-only commitment and no net change in other forcing. The bands reflect only the chosen TCRE range. They are not complete forecast uncertainty ranges.
| Starting warming | Calculated total after 25 more years | Calculated total after 50 more years |
|---|---|---|
| 1.5°C | 1.95°C (1.77–2.13°C) | 2.40°C (2.04–2.76°C) |
| 2.0°C | 2.45°C (2.27–2.63°C) | 2.90°C (2.54–3.26°C) |
| 2.5°C* | 2.95°C (2.77–3.13°C) | 3.40°C (3.04–3.76°C) |
| 3.0°C* | 3.45°C (3.27–3.63°C) | 3.90°C (3.54–4.26°C) |
| 3.5°C* | 3.95°C (3.77–4.13°C) | 4.40°C (4.04–4.76°C) |
| 4.0°C* | 4.45°C (4.27–4.63°C) | 4.90°C (4.54–5.26°C) |
| 4.5°C* | 4.95°C (4.77–5.13°C) | 5.40°C (5.04–5.76°C) |
| 5.0°C* | 5.45°C (5.27–5.63°C) | 5.90°C (5.54–6.26°C) |
*High-warming arithmetic extrapolation. The IPCC Technical Summary states high confidence in the near-linear relationship over this century for warming levels up to at least 2°C. Extending the same coefficient to warmer starts is an illustration, not a validated assessment for those rows. Carbon-sink changes and other feedbacks could alter the result. [12]
Illustration 3 Starting warming and another 50 years of emissions
The accompanying chart displays the 50-year column. Each open circle is a starting temperature; the filled circle shows the calculated total. The horizontal band spans the TCRE sensitivity range. Dashed connections identify high-warming extrapolations.

Worked example: start at 1.5°C, continue emitting 40 GtCO₂ annually for 50 years, and this calculation gives 2.40°C total, with a 2.04–2.76°C sensitivity band. That does not mean reaching 1.5°C alone has already made 2.40°C unavoidable. Reducing future emissions reduces the addition.
How clean air and methane change the near-term result
Aerosols are tiny particles or droplets in the air. Some human-made aerosols reflect sunlight and change clouds in ways that cool the planet. Many disappear within days to weeks after emissions stop, while surface temperatures take longer to respond. [6]
Samset and colleagues’ 2018 experiment isolated the removal of anthropogenic aerosols and found 0.5–1.1°C of global warming, around 0.7°C across its models. This is an aerosol-removal experiment, not a universal extra amount to add to every net-zero scenario. Its thermal response unfolds over years to decades and longer; disappearance of the particles is much faster than full temperature adjustment. [10]
Methane reductions work in the opposite direction by reducing a relatively short-lived warming influence. A complete fossil-fuel transition changes several drivers together. Therefore a CO₂-only zero-emissions estimate, an isolated aerosol-removal estimate and a slow-feedback estimate cannot simply be added: some effects overlap, some offset and their timing differs. [3], [6]
The practical response is to improve air quality while cutting CO₂ and methane rapidly. Keeping harmful pollution as a cooling strategy would exchange one serious problem for another.
Tipping points can amplify warming and lock in lasting damage
A tipping point is a threshold beyond which a part of the climate system can enter a self-perpetuating change. The warming level at which that becomes possible is usually a range, and the time spent warm matters. Armstrong McKay and colleagues find that several tipping elements may be triggered in the 1.5°C to below-2°C range, with more at higher warming. [14]
Many major climate tipping processes can reinforce global warming, through changes that begin relatively quickly or unfold over centuries to millennia. Thawing permafrost can release carbon dioxide and methane. Widespread Amazon forest loss can release stored carbon and reduce the forest’s ability to remove carbon dioxide from the atmosphere. Loss of reflective ice exposes darker surfaces that absorb more sunlight. These warming influences can increase pressure on other systems, raising the risk of further tipping and cascading changes.
Difficulty calculating an exact additional temperature increase does not mean that these warming influences are absent or negligible. There are genuine exceptions: collapse of the Atlantic overturning circulation can cool the North Atlantic region and reduce global average temperature compared with an otherwise similar climate, while causing severe disruption. The evidence therefore supports treating warming amplification and cascading risks as major concerns, while examining each system’s effects, interactions and timescale separately.
| Sustained warming condition | Committed consequence reported by IPCC | Time |
|---|---|---|
| Warming limited to 1.5°C | About 2–3 metres of global mean sea-level rise; low confidence in the numerical range. | Over the next 2,000 years. |
| Warming limited to 2°C | About 2–6 metres of global mean sea-level rise; low confidence in the numerical range. | Over the next 2,000 years. |
| Sustained warming between 2°C and 3°C | Near-complete, irreversible Greenland and West Antarctic ice-sheet loss; limited evidence. | Multiple millennia. |
These are long-term consequences, not sea levels expected by 2100. [15]
Why CO₂ and CO₂ equivalent need different labels
CO₂ concentration measures carbon dioxide in the atmosphere, usually in parts per million. CO₂-equivalent concentration expresses the heat-trapping effect of a specified mixture as an equivalent amount of CO₂. The mixture might include only greenhouse gases or also aerosol cooling; the boundary must be stated. [18]
A CO₂-equivalent emissions figure measured in tonnes is a different quantity from a CO₂-equivalent concentration measured in parts per million. Neither a temperature threshold nor an emissions-equivalence number supplies a complete forecast of equilibrium warming.
What to do next with this information
- Ask for the missing condition. Whenever you see “baked in,” ask: zero emissions, fixed concentrations, continued emissions or continued policies?
- Ask for the clock and the baseline. Is the number additional or total? Is it for 50 years, 2100, 1,000 years or eventual equilibrium? What event starts the clock?
- Reduce the source of additional risk. Support rapid CO₂ cuts, strong methane reductions and protection of carbon-storing ecosystems. Net zero must describe the physical emissions balance, not just an announced target.
- Prepare with other people. Compare heat, fire, flood, water and power risks with a neighbor or local group. No household will have enough of everything in a major disruption; cooperation expands what is available. Start with one useful shared task.
- Use a practical plan. The Job One for Humanity Plan B offers preparation, adaptation, resilience and climate-action steps.
Conclusion
Reaching a warming level does not mean Earth has finished responding. Under a fixed heat-trapping influence, delayed warming can continue for centuries and longer. Under net-zero CO₂, declining atmospheric CO₂ can offset much of that delayed warming over decades. Under continued emissions, further warming keeps being created.
For households, communities and decision-makers, the useful question is therefore: what warming and damage follow under which choices, and over how long? Keeping those conditions visible makes the danger clearer and shows why reducing every avoidable fraction of warming still matters.
Frequently asked questions
Does 1.5°C automatically commit us to 2°C
No. Additional warming is conditional on forcing, emissions, feedbacks and history. A particular pathway can pass 2°C after crossing 1.5°C, but crossing alone does not establish that outcome.
Does net-zero CO₂ immediately cool the planet
No. The central expectation is approximately stable CO₂-caused surface warming over decades. Other gases, aerosols and slower responses can change the total outcome.
Does one year above 1.5°C mean the long-term threshold has been crossed
A single year and a long-term warming level are different measurements. Climate states and targets are assessed over decades; unusual annual warmth can sit above the longer-term trend. [16]
Can the higher scientific estimates be dismissed because they are not central estimates
No. Higher sensitivities, slow feedbacks and broad upper tails are relevant to risk assessment. Their assumptions and timescales must remain attached to them.
Can we add all the upper estimates together
No. A high-sensitivity equilibrium calculation may already include feedbacks that another estimate isolates. Adding overlapping effects double counts warming.
Are the continued-emissions table bands complete future temperature ranges
No. They show arithmetic sensitivity to one published coefficient, with emissions and non-CO₂ forcing specified. High-warming rows extrapolate beyond the strongest assessed domain.
Why not give an arrival year for every threshold
Temperature alone does not determine either the destination or the speed. A credible arrival estimate requires a specified emissions or forcing pathway and a model that resolves the relevant feedbacks.
Is it ever too late to reduce future warming
Earlier reductions prevent more risk, and later reductions still reduce additional emissions and harm. Some consequences can become difficult or impossible to reverse on human timescales, which makes early action more valuable.
Glossary
- Additional warming: The temperature change after a stated starting point. It can be positive or negative.
- Aerosols: Small airborne particles or droplets that can affect sunlight and clouds; their net human-made effect has been cooling.
- Carbon sink: A process or reservoir that takes up more carbon than it releases over a stated period.
- CO₂: Carbon dioxide, a major long-lived greenhouse gas.
- CO₂ equivalent: A way to express a specified mixture of climate influences in comparable CO₂ units; concentration and emissions versions are different.
- Commitment: A future response conditional on the stated physical state and future assumptions. It does not always mean unavoidable.
- ECS: Equilibrium climate sensitivity: eventual warming for sustained doubled CO₂ under the feedback definition used.
- Equilibrium: A state of balance after adjustment; a model equilibrium is not necessarily the temperature Earth will actually reach.
- Feedback: A response that amplifies or reduces an initial change.
- Forcing: A change in Earth’s energy balance imposed by factors such as greenhouse gases, aerosols or solar changes.
- GtCO₂: One billion metric tonnes of carbon dioxide. It is not the same as a billion tonnes of carbon.
- Net-zero CO₂: Human-caused CO₂ emissions balanced by human-caused CO₂ removals. Natural land and ocean uptake can continue separately.
- Pattern effect: Changes in climate response caused by where warming occurs, especially across the oceans.
- PgC: One billion metric tonnes of carbon. Multiply by about 3.67 to express the mass as CO₂.
- Pre-industrial baseline: The 1850–1900 average used here unless a source-specific experiment states otherwise.
- TCRE: Transient climate response to cumulative CO₂ emissions: warming per total quantity of CO₂ emitted.
- Tipping point: A threshold beyond which a part of the climate system can develop self-perpetuating change.
- Total warming: The temperature difference from the specified pre-industrial or experiment baseline.
- ZEC₅₀: Zero-CO₂-emissions commitment measured about 50 years after emissions cease, generally using a 20-year average.
AI Prompt Support
- Explain committed warming using three cases: zero net CO₂ emissions, fixed atmospheric concentrations and continued annual emissions. Identify the assumptions, baseline and timescale for every number.
- Check this warming claim against primary sources. Separate additional warming from total warming, and probability intervals from model spreads. Show any overlapping effects that would be double counted.
- Compare the IPCC, Hansen and Zhou results without treating different experiments as opposing forecasts of the same future. Include central estimates, upper tails and the conditions that generate them.
- What is absent, excluded, lost, or not yet developed—and how does that affect what this climate model is, what it can do, and what it could become?
Linked bibliography
Bracketed references in the article link to these entries. Most sources are original studies or official assessments; the NASA records reproduce publication abstracts.
- IPCC AR6 Working Group I Chapter 4 (2021). Section 4.7 and Table 4.8 distinguish commitment experiments and assess CO₂ zero-emissions commitment.
- MacDougall and colleagues Is there warming in the pipeline (2020). ZECMIP experiments at 750, 1,000 and 2,000 PgC; includes the funding-only corrigendum.
- Palazzo Corner and colleagues The Zero Emissions Commitment and climate stabilization (2023). Review of physical processes, carbon sinks, missing feedbacks and longer timescales.
- Sanderson and colleagues flat10MIP (2025). New emissions-driven experiments testing positive, zero and negative CO₂ emissions.
- Hohn and colleagues Probabilistic constraints on the zero emissions commitment (2026). Perturbed-parameter experiments in one Earth system model; published October 20, 2026.
- Mauritsen and Pincus Committed warming inferred from observations (2017). Historical observational estimates under several assumptions about fossil-fuel cessation and carbon uptake.
- Zhou and colleagues Greater committed warming after accounting for the pattern effect (2021). Fixed-forcing estimates, dataset sensitivity and very wide upper tails. Author manuscript hosted by the US National Science Foundation.
- Hansen and colleagues Global warming in the pipeline (2023). Higher equilibrium climate sensitivity and slow-feedback equilibrium warming; NASA publication record and abstract.
- Hansen and colleagues Global Warming Has Accelerated (2025). Figure 14 and accompanying discussion of delayed response to fixed doubled CO₂; NASA-hosted journal reprint.
- Samset and colleagues Climate impacts from a removal of anthropogenic aerosol emissions (2018). Model experiment isolating warming caused by removing anthropogenic aerosols; NASA publication record.
- Frölicher and Paynter Extending the relationship between global warming and cumulative carbon emissions to multi-millennial timescales (2015). A model example with about 0.5°C additional warming after emissions stop at 2°C.
- IPCC AR6 Working Group I Technical Summary (2021). TS.3.2.1 gives assessed equilibrium climate sensitivity ranges and transient-response definitions.
- IPCC AR6 Synthesis Report Summary for Policymakers (2023). Section B.5 gives the warming response to cumulative CO₂ emissions and explains net zero.
- Armstrong McKay and colleagues Exceeding 1.5°C global warming could trigger multiple climate tipping points (2022). Science review of tipping thresholds and self-perpetuating changes; PubMed record and abstract.
- IPCC AR6 Synthesis Report Full Volume (2023). SPM B.3.1 and B.3.2 discuss millennial sea-level and ice-sheet commitments.
- World Meteorological Organization Confirmation of 2024 global temperature (2025). Distinguishes a single year above 1.5°C from long-term warming measured over decades.
- IPCC AR5 Frequently Asked Questions (2013). FAQ 12.3 explains the historical fixed-concentration warming commitment, about 0.6°C over the century from year-2000 conditions.
- IPCC AR5 Synthesis Report Glossary (2014). Distinguishes CO₂-equivalent concentration, CO₂-equivalent emissions and forcing.
- Hansen and colleagues Global Warming Has Accelerated supplementary material (2025). Explains that full equilibrium including slow feedbacks would require millennia and can be avoided through greenhouse gas drawdown.
- Friedlingstein and colleagues Global Carbon Budget 2025 (2026). Context for the illustrative 40 GtCO₂ annual emissions assumption; estimates about 42.2 GtCO₂ for 2025.
Your next step: choose one action from Plan B, and help one other person distinguish a conditional warming estimate from an unavoidable outcome.
Article Author Information
This document was created by Lawrence Wollersheim, Senior DMAP analyst at the Universe Institute. AI also helped research, assemble, and verify the accuracy of this article.
Do you like this page?